X Factor group The Risk made their second live performance with their new line up tonight and received a mixed reaction from the judges, with Gary Barlow saying the group needed to realise Charlie was their lead singer.
Kelly Rowland told the boys: "I was a little bit nervous but I'm so glad you did it! Give everything you got, good performance this week guys"
Take That star Gary Barlow commented: "This was your best song choice yet, but the vocals were lacking for me tonight, not as good as your previous performances."
Louis Walsh said: "WOW! Boys, after that performance you've put yourself back in the race. Charlie, you're the main man, I love everything about you."
The Risk's mentor Tulisa added: "I have got nothing negative to say tonight, well done you guys! You smashed it! You won this competition tonight!"