The X Factor 2012 stars took to the stage for the fourth time on Saturday night, but who did you rate?
The remaining contestants took on spooky Halloween tracks, at least that was meant to be the idea.
However Jade Ellis was slated by the panel, and favourite Ella Henderson also got some criticism from Nicole over her song choice.
And Rylan's mashup of three more tracks - including his mentor's own Poison - still didn't convince Gary Barlow.
But who did you rate?
Vote for your X Factor 2012 favourite in our latest popularity poll below...
[cat c="the x factor"]The X Factor 2012[/cat] continues this Saturday night with a spooky Halloween themed episode as the remaining ten contestants perform live once again.
The latest results show follows on Sunday, which will feature performances from Fun. and Robbie Williams, as well as one more act being given the boot.